In answer to the original question..no.
The reality is that it is the senior civil servants who run the Island, not politicians. Whilst most politicians come into politics with good intentions, many are quickly thwarted by civil servants giving them a raft of spurious reasons why something isn’t a good idea, or they make all the right brown nose noises, but then do everything in their power to move their idea along at a glacial pace.
The only successful politicians are those whose intelligence, determination and whit is greater than the civil servants they are trying to work with to progress their idea..and such a beast is very few and far between.
To be honest, if all MHKs went off sick for 6 months nobody would notice and the wheels would keep turning.
Its my strong opinion that we only need 10 MHKs, paid very well so as to attract really strong candidates.
As for Alf, he does seem to be hanging on by his fingernails..to be honest, who’d want his job. Howard just about got away with it using the “fake it until you make it” mantra and the fact a fair chunk of his tour of duty was in COVID when nothing else mattered anyway saw him through, but Alf seems to be running out of road.